Petrol Engine or Diesel Engine: Your Choice?


Which is your pick?


  • Total voters
    113
Joined
Aug 1, 2014
Messages
428
Likes
461
Location
Somewhere in MH
All this "surge of power", "leaving petrols behind at traffic lights" blah-blah is because we compare turbo charged diesels to normal petrols.
I don't know much about the other points, but for cheaper cars, we should keep in mind that we pay more excise duty when the displacement of petrols is more than 1200 cc, while we pay the same duty when the displacement is more than 1500 cc for diesels. Now, the best one can manage with the 12% excise slab, is 1199 cc turbocharged petrol, while for the diesels the figure is 1499 cc turbocharged. IMO, a 1499 cc Diesel engine should at least be equivalent to a 1199 cc petrol engine. Take the case of VW Polo GT twins. Both take about 11 secs. to reach 100 km/h. (Not the exact fig, but I think it should suffice.). Even in this competition, the TSI is heavily aided by the 7 speed DSG.

Let us say that there is a 1500 cc Polo TSI. Now there would be few buyers who would spend close to 11 big ones (Remember, you pay 24% for any petrol car whose displacement is > 1200 cc... Correct me if I'm wrong) for a petrol hatchback, whose fuel costs are a bit too much, isn't it.

The same is not true for more premium cars, but the turbocharged petrol cars below 20L can be counted of fingers. Tata Revotron: Zest, Bolt. VW TSI: Polo GT TSI, Vento. Fiat T-jet: Linea T-jet. Ford: Ecosport EcoBoost. (Not including Audi here.) I can't recall anything else. While most diesels are turbocharged. It is true however, that diesels are more expensive then their petrol counterparts.

Above all this, one can still argue that Petrol-automatic combos outnumber Diesel-automatic combos.

Hope I was being clear here :smile:

And Happy Independence Day :smile: Jai Hind!
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jun 4, 2014
Messages
1,477
Likes
854
Location
Coimbatore
When did this turned into fight? It's not about which is cheaper or more torque-ier!! It's all about one's preference. When I was TD-ing GT twins, I started my TD with TDI and quite impressive. But after getting the TD of TSI, I've never thought about TDI!! Honestly, even if I leave the poor refinement of TDI, still TSI is way more fun than TDI. But that's just my preference. Doesn't mean I hate diesel, but I prefer Petrol over diesel given a option!!!
 

Top Bottom