As much as I personally dont like VAG cars for its cons or even Compact Sedans at all , Ameo should have made this list
It has the best build of the bunch, very enthusiastic engine etc
Only let downs are hard clutch in diesel diesel, DSG reliabilty woes and initial lag in DSG otherwise a solid performer
Aspire is next on my list thanks to its great diesel engine, good after sales and pricing
Amaze has a good diesel,though not as refined as the competition too and all round maintenance etc is a breeze, suspension is pretty stiff
Xcent is pretty ok but its no enthusiast car, engine is a gem in traffic as such but loses out on highways etc. More of a city car and has pretty good suspension, very cushioned . Steering isnt very direct, tough to centre
Zest is a good car as such especially with the 1.3 MJD and even the Revtron , looks arent the best in my eyes, looks more proportionate than Dzire though . It has aged a bit faster than the competition in my eyes but projectors etc look great .
Dzire , I only love the 1.3 MJD and k series part of this car, not a fan of its looks or handling especially the facelifted one. If I were to buy one, itd only be because of the engines personally. I find Ertiga more value for money . Upcoming Dzire might change my perception based on initial leaks.
Tigor has pretty good looking rear, excellent speakers etc but engines are a let down. If they gave it a 1.3 MJD and priced it properly , itd fly off the shelves. I havent TD the car(obviously), so these are my initial impressions). Suspension of Tiago was a bit stiff, engine lacked punch especially the diesel.
All in all, I wouldnt personally select this category of cars and find C segment base models more value for money since they are made from scratch etc. Ameo, Aspire would be my personal pick of the bunch if I were to buy a CS
^^ Just my personal views , no offense intended