Sorry for the late response; week end, you know.
I have not touched either of these phones nor checked the reviews. But, I had used two great Moto phones: SLVR L7 (2006 to I think 2009) and Atrix 2. I said in my Lenovo Vibe Pi1 review "A Moto is a Moto
In basic telephony, a Moto always stands out. Many years back, while on official duty, I spent two months in Pokhran. I was using the Nokia 5800 then. Where we stayed, my default BSNL signal was week (13 km straight line distance from Guest house to the BSNL tower - I know, as I have used DGPS to measure, just for the heck of it. I took an Airtel SIM and used it with the Nokia. When I used the BSNL SIM in the SLVR L7, I started receiving calls, clearly ! A Moto ... is ... Moto.
I advice you to see what YOU want the most in YOUR Phone. Whichever phone offers that, get that. If both meet the target, get the Moto. Good luck. PS:
Why not check out the Asus 2 Laser? When a colleague showed me that, it impressed me. After moto, I think I have become a fan of Asus and Lenovo, for their sincere efforts
and offerings. I am holding onto my 1+1, because it is a damn great phone even now PS to PS:
Mandatory confusion created. I am satisfied now.